I have serious reservations regarding the overarching narrative of sustainability as presented in the Sustainability Appraisal. It appears to define sustainability in a narrow manner, largely focused on economic growth and environmental preservation without sufficiently considering social equity. Such a limited perspective could lead to policies that inadvertently favour certain demographics and neglect others, particularly those already marginalised. The appraisal must include criteria that examine the social implications of economic development initiatives, ensuring that sustainable development translates into equitable outcomes for all community members. This holistic view is essential for true sustainability.